Who would do such an awful thing? Twenty-four year old Shell Hodge is in the final stretch of her quest for a master's degree in art history when tragedy strikes at her art co-op near the University of Texas at Austin. She finds the body of beautiful Dr. Leone, her art teacher from UT, and she is forced to endure an aggressive interview by the police. Believing that the approach of the detectives is unlikely to result in the capture of the real murderer, Shell embarks on her own search for answers. A circle of clues leads back to her best friend's ex, Jeremy. Meanwhile, that same best friend, Margie, has some ideas of her own about Jeremy, one of them being that she wants to keep her little dog and herself as far away from him as possible. Enlisting the help of a handsome psychologist seems like a good idea at first, but learning that he also has a secret and that it, too, leads back to the murder victim, puts Margie on an emotional rollercoaster, while Shell winds up at the point of death when she finds herself facing a killer.